News & Insights

Defined benefit schemes – a ‘ticking time bomb’?

A similar story goes for Tata Steel UK and its pension deficit, which currently stands at around £700m. The company believes that separating the scheme from Tata Steel UK is necessary because otherwise it would be “highly unlikely” that a purchaser would take it on. Changes in legislation are currently considered to reduce the long term liabilities towards its 130,000 members by billions of pounds. This move, however, would set a serious precedent for other troubled schemes.

What both Tata Steel UK and BHS have in common – apart from not being able to make a profit – is that their pension liabilities were accumulated when the number of employees was growing and most were young. Unaffordable promises have been exposed by contraction, low returns on capital and increasing life expectancy. This problem is widespread as it is estimated that the UK private sector pension schemes have combined liabilities of £1.6 trillion which is about the same as the market capitalisation of the FTSE 100 constituents today.

Ten years ago, there were a total of around 7,000 defined benefit schemes in the UK, with an average funding (able to meet liabilities) of around 90%.  Today there are less than 6,000 schemes with an average funding of around 80%. It is clear that there is a problem.

Pension risk may well be one of the main risks for FTSE 100 companies with legacy defined benefit pension schemes. Since January 2005, it is estimated that the total pension liability of FTSE 100 companies has almost doubled.

So, how serious is it and who’s next?  

Based on the information in existing accounting disclosures, BAE Systems, BT Group, International Airlines Group (British Airways), Sainsbury’s and RSA Insurance Group are companies that all may be running significant levels of pension risk relative to the size of their business. The average FTSE 100 pension liability was 35% of market capitalisation but, for example, International Airlines Group’s accounting liabilities were more than double the size of its market capitalisation. As Michael O’Leary already quoted back in 2009: “British Airways is just a pension deficit with wings”.

So, this raises the next question: will anyone allow companies the size of the above, to become bankrupt or bailed out? Of course not. It becomes very clear that promises made in the past are only as viable as the reality allows it to be. There are simply not enough people working to fund these payments.  

So, who will suffer?

The FT published last week that MP Frank Field has launched an inquiry into defined benefit pensions to find “radical solutions” to the increasing pressures on retirement savings posed by rising life expectancy and stubbornly low investment returns. The Work and Pensions Select Committee Chair said unsustainable promises made to scheme members were being “stacked up against” the jobs of younger generations. Without urgent action, “the impact on millions of people’s living standards from intergenerational trade-offs of income and wealth are brutal”, he said.  

Although not clear what “radical solutions” mean, it is to be expected that they will include reductions in member benefits.

Then there are the defined contribution schemes. Since April 2015, defined contribution schemes have become more attractive as individuals can access their pension savings with much greater flexibility than previously – the so-called “flexible access”. People can pass on capital to their spouse and next generations.  

Add this flexibility to the massive problems final salary schemes are facing, and you can ask yourself when it would be a good time to have a look at yours. As a member of a final salary scheme (defined benefit scheme), you have options. Make sure you look at yours to make an informed decision whilst you still can.  The clock is ticking… 


This communication is for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute, and should not be construed as, investment advice, investment recommendations or investment research. You should seek advice from a professional adviser before embarking on any financial planning activity. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the information contained in this communication is correct, we are not responsible for any errors or omissions.

Other News

Portugal becomes Europe’s most popular destination for American Expats

Research reveals that Portugal is quickly becoming the favourite location for Americans moving overseas to Europe, outranking the previously preferred destinations of Spain and France for the first time. With its beautiful and varied landscape, fantastic food and welcoming locals, Portugal has always been a popular location for expats, both working and retired. However, in […]

Read More

Getting your numbers right

During the last political year, we have been given statistic after statistic by politicians who sound like they know what they are talking about. They can, at times, sound very convincing and even believable. But how do we know what is right and what is not?  The average person has no idea how much being a member of the EU costs per day. While even experts don’t know precisely how much the UK will save by not having to pay the EU after it exits the European Union.

Read More

Select your country

Please select your country of residence so we can provide you with the most relevant information:

You are currently viewing the Blacktower Financial Management EU website.

You may be looking for the Blacktower United Kingdom website.

Blacktower United Kingdom > X Stay on this site

Or choose your country.